When to Thanksgiving Prep? Summer season’s Not Too Early for This Mother.

As a part of our 52 Days of Thanksgiving, we’re providing you with all of the instruments and tricks to pull off one of the best Thanksgiving ever, from setting a trendy desk to curating the last word menu. Join emails right here to unlock the secrets and techniques of planning probably the most memorable feast of the yr.

This summer season, we shared a narrative on our Instagram a few Thanksgiving dinner so over-the-top it sparked almost 7,000 likes and greater than 100 feedback, most expressing pure admiration.

The feast was extraordinary not simply because it included an astounding 25 appetizers, mains, sides, and desserts for a visitor checklist of round 35 household and pals—however due to how early the host started cooking it.

In Sherri Maxman’s ode to her mom Anita Steinfeld’s vacation dinner—which we first revealed in 2015—she recounts how, as early as August, her mother would pull out her deep freezer and start cranking out the dishes she might make forward of time: fried onions (Steinfeld household slang for caramelized onions, destined for her heat chopped liver and recent challah), sweet-and-sour meatballs, gravy, stuffing, spinach artichoke dip, baked ziti, cornbread, vanilla butter, and candy potato hash. Knocking these out early allowed her mother to concentrate on every part else that wanted to be made nearer to or on Thanksgiving—an epic supper that included ham, steak, lamb chops, and deep-fried turkeys, plural.

It was a beautiful, beneficiant, unbelievable feat—that, as I discussed, was final documented eight years in the past. So, naturally, I questioned: Is Anita nonetheless on the range (and deep freezer)?

Curious if this household custom was nonetheless alive, and the way it has advanced over time, I made a decision to succeed in out to Sherri. The excellent news: Although she’s not the host, Mother remains to be cooking up a storm. And, though the final time everybody got here to her Lengthy Island house was in 2017, she is nonetheless making her chopped liver and fried onions to convey to a good friend’s home for the vacation.

She additionally hasn’t stopped freezing her meals, a trick she discovered when she was 14 years outdated.

Anita on a current household trip.

Picture by Sherri Maxman

“My mom labored, and I used to make dinners,” mentioned Anita, who now lives in Hollywood, Florida and can flip 82 in October. “In these days they got here out with the TV dinner. So I used to save lots of the dishes that they had been in after which if I might make one thing for dinner that I might like, I might make my very own TV dinner and stick it within the freezer!”

Now that she is not planning her personal Thanksgiving—she spends it with pals close by who used to return to her home on Lengthy Island—I requested her if she felt a way of aid.

“No, I prefer to prepare dinner,” mentioned Anita, who very a lot misses internet hosting the vacation. “I nonetheless do and I nonetheless have individuals over for dinner. That is my factor. It is at all times been my factor.”

Like her mom, Sherri—a former pastry chef and culinary teacher—is obsessed with cooking, too. She simply throws a Thanksgiving feast on a smaller scale together with her brother’s household and her personal. (Nobody is up for touring for the vacation, and everyone seems to be OK with that.)

“Even when my mother did her extravaganzas,” mentioned Sherri, “I’d have by no means needed them to finish. However, somewhat a part of me thought, sometime I am gonna be doing this and I will simply tweak it and adapt it to do the issues that I wish to do.”

Sherri begins her Thanksgiving prep like most of us do: within the fall. Except for the caramelized onions—which she makes nicely prematurely—she begins menu planning in October and does not start cooking till the week of. “Persons are so excited once they hear that they’ll make fried onions forward of time as a result of lots of people do not understand they’ll try this,” she mentioned.

Sherri in her kitchen on Thanksgiving final yr.

Picture by Courtesy Sherri Maxman

It’s the basic Thanksgiving altering of the guard. Till you host the vacation your self, there’s not a lot tinkering you are able to do to the menu. Solely once you develop into the planner and prepare dinner is it doable to innovate and drop issues from the lineup with out (an excessive amount of) guilt. And even then, the dishes you skip usually depart deep cravings.

Sherri’s menu from 2022, you may hint the lineage from her mother’s feasts to hers. The challah, liver, and onions are a should. “That’s a non-negotiable,” mentioned Sherri.

Like her mom’s meal, turkey just isn’t the one meat concerned—brisket has made an look, as have meatball sliders, a nod to Anita’s meatballs (generally sweet-and-sour, generally spicy and stuffed). Sherri additionally bakes a handful of Thanksgiving pies, a dessert Anita handed over in favor of jelly donuts. “All of us love them and haven’t made them but for our feasts,” mentioned Sherri, “however we’re at all times eager about it!”

Final yr, Sherri and her brother launched a “radical change” to their menu. “My brother mentioned, ‘We spend all day cooking on Thanksgiving. We eat a lot, no one may even eat the primary course. Let’s do the appetizers on Wednesday evening and the primary course and the edges on Thursday evening.’ Proper? And all of us thought that [was] good. A brand new custom is born.”

So which fashion of Thanksgiving, Sherri’s or Anita’s, is extra you?

Judging from the response to our Instagram put up about Anita’s heroic head begin on Thanksgiving, a few of you are feeling seen. “Omg I assumed I used to be the one one!” wrote certainly one of our followers.

Others expressed admiration for a feat they might by no means pull off themselves: “I can’t even decide my outfit out the day earlier than. God bless her.”

If you happen to contemplate your self workforce Anita, under is every part she made and froze prematurely of Thanksgiving for inspiration. We even have a information to meals that freeze nicely, and make-ahead Thanksgiving dishes.

You too can take it straightforward like Sherri, and begin cooking at a extra typical time, like November. That can assist you plot out your meal, we’ve a useful timeline that can assist you plan Thanksgiving, together with the menu of Sherri’s dinner final yr (together with her appetizer-only pre-game the night earlier than).

Picture by Bobbi Lin

Anita’s 2015 Thanksgiving Menu

Beneath, we’ve sprinkled in hyperlinks to related, test-kitchen authorised recipes on our website.

Made months prematurely

Spinach and artichoke dip

Caramelized onions


Baked pastas




Chocolate or vanilla butter

Candy potato hash browns

Gravy for deep-fried turkey

Served on Thanksgiving Day

(Psst! A few of these dishes had been made a day or two earlier than!)

Chopped liver, fried onions, and challah

Spinach and artichoke dip

Vegetable dip

Mussels with basil bread crumbs

Gravlax and molasses lox

Mini lasagna

Spicy stuffed meatballs

Crabmeat quiche

Rib lamb chops

Shrimp cocktail

Deep fried turkeys

Glazed ham

Sliced steak

Candy potato hash browns

Baked ziti

Nathan’s fries

Roasted garlic

Cucumber salad

Lime Jell-O mildew

Jellied cranberry sauce with Mandarin oranges

Cornbread with vanilla butter

Pretzel sticks rolled in chocolate and bacon

Jelly donuts and ice cream sundaes

Sherri’s 2022 Thanksgiving Menu

Prepped two days forward


Spinach and artichoke dip

Dough for rolls

Dough for apple tart

Pie crust

Prepped sooner or later forward


Chocolate cream pie

Inexperienced bean casserole

Mashed candy potatoes with marshmallows
Dry brine turkey

Cranberry sauce


Wednesday Night time Appetizer Feast



Spinach and artichoke dip

Corn salad

Spice-Roasted Cauliflower with Pine Nuts & Tahini Drizzle (Sherri usually makes hers with walnuts when pine nuts usually are not available)

Meatball sliders

Mashed candy potatoes with marshmallows

Scorching fudge pudding cake

Thanksgiving Dinner

Caesar salad




Inexperienced bean casserole

Mashed potatoes

Cranberry sauce

Roasted carrots and onions

Chocolate cream pie

Apple tart

Extra entertaining inspiration from Food52

Which finish of the Thanksgiving planning spectrum do you fall upon? Tell us under!

This site uses cookies to offer you a better browsing experience. By browsing this website, you agree to our use of cookies.