This text is a part of a product-testing sequence known as Food52 Accepted, a column the place we completely strive, check, and evaluate the kitchen and residential merchandise you’ve got at all times puzzled about. Food52 earns an affiliate fee on qualifying purchases of the merchandise we hyperlink to.
Cooks and diehard residence cooks love to like fish spatulas. (Do not consider us? Behold exhibit A, B, C, D, and E.) They discuss how nimbly they transfer in a pan, how sturdy they’re for his or her very gentle weight, and that they can be utilized not only for their namesake fish however something you’d wish to flip or toss. They even double as a slotted spoon or strainer.
And their followers aren’t flawed: Fish spatulas are nice! However, regardless of numerous headlines claiming they’re the one spatula you’ll ever want, they’ll’t do all the pieces. Since they’re usually metallic, they’ll scratch the coating in nonstick pans, and with their holes, they undoubtedly can’t smash a burger flat. Plus, has anybody else seen how cussed they are often to wash?
No surprise after we polled the Food52 group, 62 p.c stated they attain for various spatulas for various jobs, and requested for us to check and evaluate the Spatula Metropolis panorama. As one woeful reader wrote in, “I can’t—for the lifetime of me—discover a spatula I like.”
How We Examined
We reviewed 15 manufacturers of turner-style spatulas (no versatile bowl-scraping spatulas or offset spatulas for baking, since their functions are so completely different) and put them by three of the spatula’s most essential trials: pancake-flipping, egg-frying, and burger-smashing.
We regarded out for the most important gripes shared by our group, too. The preferred criticism was when they’re too thick to slip simply beneath meals. Others included: being both too stiff or too flimsy, not being warmth protected, not nonstick pleasant, or pesky to wash.
We’re not a lab, however we’re a group of opinionated residence cooks and one obsessive researcher and tester (that is me). Beneath are my favourite spatulas for fixing the most typical cooking issues—I’d love to listen to yours within the feedback, too.
A Nice (Extra Than) Fish Spatula: Lamson Versatile Stainless-Metal Slotted Spatula
Nice For: Searing fish and different proteins, flipping pancakes, and lifting and tossing roasted greens.
Professionals: Light-weight and nimble within the pan, angled strategically for flipping and lifting, and is available in left-handed and right-handed variations. (Confession: By way of testing, I discovered I’m a right-handed one who’s been utilizing a left-handed Lamson for at the least a decade—nonetheless works nice!)
Cons: Can’t use in nonstick pans, can’t smash a burger, not dishwasher protected, and the skinny metallic and holes are tough to wash.
Nonstick-Friendliest (Silicone): GIR Flip
Nice For: Gliding easily beneath pancakes, French toast, and fried eggs.
Professionals: The silicone coating slides beneath sticky meals with even much less resistance than metallic or wooden and might hug the corners of the pan like a extra conventional versatile spatula would. It has a pleasant vast paddle that’s bolstered at simply the appropriate place to make it sturdy—I’ve to confess, I used to be skeptical that it could be sturdy and sharp sufficient to free caught bits, but it surely dealt with each check surprisingly nicely. It’s additionally dishwasher protected.
Cons: It’s solely warmth protected as much as 550°F, so it is probably not protected for smoking-hot preparations like smashed burgers.
Nonstick-Friendliest (Picket): Lancaster Picket Turner Spatula
Nice For: All the fundamental flipping duties, and doubling as a wood spoon to get into corners and scrape up sticky brown bits.
Professionals: Handmade in the USA from sustainably harvested maple, cherry, or walnut, plastic-free, and protected for nonstick pans. It additionally is available in a leftie model and works surprisingly nicely—the sting is simply skinny sufficient to get beneath fried eggs and pancakes, with out feeling vulnerable to splintering (or snapping within the mail, like one other wood mannequin I ordered did).
Cons: It’s not dishwasher protected and must be oiled often, very like wood reducing boards, to keep up its power. Moreover, it is probably not as sturdy as metallic or silicone. The angle connecting the deal with to the paddle is shallow, which means your hand has to get a bit nearer to the pan than with steeper spatulas.
Greatest Smasher: Winco Blade Hamburger Turner
Nice For: Smashing the dickens out of burgers.
Professionals: This smasher is so hefty, you don’t have to use a lot stress to squash a burger in opposition to a sizzling pan instantly. The paddle is vast sufficient for bigger burgers and has an angled edge that helps it launch from the burger rapidly after smashing (and simply scrapes up all of the seared bits).
Cons: Not less than for me, an individual of fairly common wrist power, that is too heavy to be comfy with different informal sautéing and flipping. For those who’re a extra occasional smasher, one thing smaller and lighter-weight like this Dexter-Russell Pancake Turner could also be extra versatile.
Honorable Point out: 5 Two Steel Turner
For folk afraid of spattering and who desire a protected distance from the pan, this was the longest-handled spatula we examined. It has a beneficiant paddle excellent for extra-large latkes, French toast, or pancakes.
One last be aware to all of the spatula-makers on the market: One characteristic that I didn’t see in any present spatulas, that I like in my favourite classic one, is a hook on the deal with. Having a hook helps to maintain the spatula from sliding into the pan and melting the deal with—one other of our group’s greatest frustrations. (My favourite classic one additionally has a built-in ruler on the paddle! You may see it in motion right here.) So, spatula giants, are you able to assist us handle-melters out?
What options would your dream spatula have? Tell us within the feedback!