Superb Italian Cream Cake Recipe

This put up might comprise affiliate gross sales hyperlinks. Please learn my disclosure coverage.

This Italian Cream Cake Recipe is about to blow your thoughts. A light-weight vanilla primarily based layer cake, much like my vanilla cake is laced with toasted pecans and coconut, solely to be slathered in decadent cream cheese frosting. It’s a wonderful dessert, any means you slice it. 😉 See what I did there?

italian cream cake in the background with slices of cake on plates in the forefront.

First of All, What’s Italian Cream Cake?

Absolutely it’s a cake from Italy, given the identify and all. WRONG-O! This cake truly is derived from the south and there’s nothing Italian about it. After some analysis, some assume its origins are from Texas, whereas others assume it comes from Georgia. Regardless, ‘Italian Cream Cake‘ (or generally additionally known as Italian Cream Cheese Cake) is barely a reputation and on the finish of the day, you received’t care due to how scrumptious it’s.

decorated italian cream cake

The best way to Make Italian Cream Cake

Identical to making some other form of cake, the steps don’t actually range all that a lot! The toughest half is ready for the muffins to chill so you may assemble this magnificence. In fact the detailed recipe card with substances and measurements are discovered on the backside of this put up. Right here is step-by-step what you may anticipate when making this recipe:

italian cream cake ingredients

Preheat Oven + Prep Pans

Preheat oven. Line two spherical baking pans with parchment paper and nonstick cooking spray. Put aside.

We’ll find yourself chopping every cake in half to get 4 cake layers. In the event you’d wish to NOT try this, use three cake pans for 3 taller layers.

Make Cake Batter

In a big bowl, whisk the dry substances (all goal flour, baking powder, baking soda and salt) collectively. In a separate bowl or measuring cup, stir buttermilk and vanilla extract collectively. Put aside.

Within the bowl of a stand mixer, stir butter, oil and sugar collectively till mixed. Add within the eggs and egg whites and beat till very gentle and fluffy.

Alternate including within the dry substances with the buttermilk to the egg combination, beginning and ending with the dry. Fold within the pecans and coconut.


Divide batter evenly between two baking pans and bake. You should definitely place the pans within the decrease two thirds of the oven. Cake is completed when a toothpick inserted comes out clear or largely clear with a number of moist crumbs.

Cool in cake pans for 15-20 minutes earlier than inverting and transferring to a cooling rack. Permit muffins to chill utterly earlier than chopping and adorning.

Make Cream Cheese Frosting

Place all frosting substances into a big bowl. Stir with an electrical mixer (or stand mixer) till utterly mixed, thick and easy. Scrape the edges and stir once more briefly to make sure a easy frosting. Use as desired.

Assembling Your Cake

Utilizing a serrated bread knife, slice every cooled cake in half lengthwise to get 4 skinny muffins. Place one cake onto a cake plate or serving platter. Unfold about 3/4 cup of frosting onto the cake evenly (doesn’t need to be precise) being certain to push frosting proper to the perimeters of the cake. Prime with one other slice of cake. Proceed frosting and filling the cake till all 4 slices of cake are stacked on each other with frosting in between every. With remaining frosting, frost cake exterior. 

Enhance with extra coconut and pecans as desired and serve.

Adorning Your Cake

Decorations can range, relying on desire and how much adorning instruments you have got. I used a small offset spatula for all the cake! Easy, however efficient and really inviting. I really like the crunch of a pecan, so I coated the skin with nuts, and sprinkled some toasted coconut on prime. Even in case you depart your Italian Cream Cake typically plain you may nonetheless have a good looking completed product.

Storing + Make Forward Instructions

When you’ve got leftover cake and need to retailer the remaining, press plastic wrap straight on the lower parts of cake, whereas loosely wrapping the highest and edges. Retailer leftover cake within the fridge.

To Freeze: wrap cake nicely in plastic wrap and retailer within the freezer for as much as 3 months!

Make Forward: In the event you’re going to be making this cake and consuming it inside 2-3 hours, it’s completely fantastic to go away out of the counter. In the event you plan to retailer this for a number of days, then positively refrigerate. Cowl whole cake gently with plastic wrap (toothpicks protruding of the cake will assist the plastic wrap not stick).

slice of italian cream cake on a plate with a fork

FAQ’s + Baking Suggestions for Italian Cream Cake

Does Italian Cream Cake must be refrigerated?

In the event you’re going to be making this cake and consuming it inside 2-3 hours, it’s completely fantastic to go away out of the counter. In the event you plan on preserving this for a number of days, then positively refrigerate. Cowl whole cake gently with plastic wrap (toothpicks protruding of the cake will assist the plastic wrap not stick).

Do I actually need each oil and butter on this recipe?

Sure! I purposely use a mixture of butter and oil to make sure this cake stays moist. Butter provides taste and the oil provides that additional insurance coverage. Buttermilk, one other listed ingredient, additionally does the identical factor!

What does baking this cake at a decrease temperature do for the cake?

Baking muffins at a decrease oven temperature for longer interval time may also retain a number of that moisture. Simply make sure to watch it and check it as you go so that you don’t over bake! As soon as your muffins come out of the oven, allow them to cool utterly, however don’t allow them to sit out ALL DAY. The perimeters can get crusty and rancid tasting if neglected previous 12 hours. In the event you’d wish to make this cake upfront, nice! Merely wrap the cooled muffins in plastic wrap and omit on the counter or refrigerate, no matter your desire is.

Can I take advantage of 3 cake pans as a substitute of two?

Sure, you may. In the event you don’t need to slice every baked cake into two to create 4 cake layers, be at liberty to divide the cake batter between three cake pans for simply three layers. They are going to bake faster within the oven and also you received’t need to slice any muffins, making for simpler meeting.

Love Italian Cream Cake? Strive These Different Cake Recipes:

There you have got it! I hope you’re keen on this cake as a lot as I do and plan to make it in your subsequent special day. You should definitely print, save or bookmark this recipe and in case you make this recipe, I’d actually respect it in case you would give it a star overview! When you’ve got an image of your completed dish, put up it on Instagram utilizing the hashtag #laurenslatest and tagging me @laurens_latest.

italian cream cake slice